anglomedved: (Default)

For Russian readers, my article on Orthodoxy in Belgium has just been published (in Russian) in the Orthodox magazine Alpha & Omega.

I wrote it in 2012, the 150th anniversary year of Orthodoxy in Belgium – the delay is largely due to the late editor-in-chief Marina Zhurinskaya’s illness and death last October.

I penned it in reaction to the usual ‘praise-singing’ articles which accompanied the anniversary, pointing to the serious problems lying ahead of Orthodoxy in Belgium and the need for clear forward thinking. It probably applies, mutatis mutandis, to diaspora Russian Orthodoxy in other countries outside Belgium.

It is my own opinion and not any ‘official line’. It is a plea for vision and common-sense in a situation in which right now fog and fantasy prevail.

anglomedved: (Default)


Parts 1 and 2 again )


It is also about being Christian when one has mixed cultural roots. In an Orthodoxy which has tended, like Lutheranism, to define itself along national cultural lines, a cultural mongrel will inevitably be something of a misfit. As an Englishman in a Russian Church, with a strong European background, I can no longer fit into a simple ‘Russian only’ (or indeed ‘English only’) context. Ditto the Polish cleaning ladies who make up 30% of our parish. Ditto all the partners of mixed marriages. Ditto a large portion of the people whom we are supposed to witness to (in my carpentry class: Lorentino, half Belgian, half Italian, Joseph, Belgian with an Irish wife, etc. etc.).  Slowly I find myself sliding towards a ‘Mount Athos’ solution, of a Christian culture that goes beyond nationality (one token of which might be precisely to operate in English, which is rapidly becoming the ‘super-national language’ of Europe). This seems to me to align better with the Christian calling to be ‘gathered from among the nations’ (Psalm 105,49, Psalm 106,2, 1 Peter 2.9) than any ‘national’ Christian culture, whether Orthodox or Lutheran.

All this begs I know, the question: why be Orthodox at all? And it is a very valid question for any serious Orthodox Christian outside the traditional Orthodox territories, especially as it is possible, in my opinion, to live an essentially Orthodox spirituality as a communicant member of the Roman Catholic Church (of the Anglican and Lutheran churches I am less sure). I do not believe being Orthodox makes you automatically a superior Christian to members of other churches. Yes, Orthodoxy has a rich spiritual tradition, which, when lived properly – by the spirit and not by the letter – can be very good and is a valuable contribution to the wider Christian world. But like everything good, it has its downside. And in this I include the way diaspora Orthodox communities quickly becoming in-grown, with fighting for ecclesiastical status (starting with the right to belong to the altar party and swan around in black cassock) taking precedence over a concern for holiness.

"Swanning around in black cassocks"
A not quite Orthodox illustration, yes I know.


Certainly, our witness to Christ in Belgium requires us to work with the other Christian churches. And yes, there will be inevitable questions of legitimate and illegitimate crossing of boundaries. Let us not be frightened by this. Let us have the honesty to say publicly that an Orthodox Christian is not damned by taking Roman Catholic communion (for example at a Scout camp), nor should an Orthodox priest be squeamish at occasionally and discreetly giving communion to believing non-Orthodox (like the many husbands of Russian wives).

This is our role: to be relevant Christians in Belgium. Not to wander aimlessly in a non-man’s land, using language and cultural difference as an excuse for inactivity. Do this and we are, in the Gospel words, “salt that has lost its savour, and is good for nothing than to be thrown under foot.” I hope we at St Nicholas do not become this.


anglomedved: (Default)

Yes, I can get exasperated at the management of our diocese, bitter at the way that some of my colleagues sacrificially work their butts off for very little – or no - money,  while others come and go as they please or build up power positions, and Moscow does not seem to care a tinker’s cuss.

But something tells me that this may be symptomatic of something much deeper: of a fundamental incoherence in the position of the Orthodox Church outside its ‘home’ territories.

Remember the story of Macdonalds and the Idaho potatoes?


Read more... )


anglomedved: (Default)

At the request of a Russian journalist friend, my wife and I have just written a long interview of me, in Russian, for one of the major Russian church sites, on how I see the position of the Russian diaspora church in Belgium.

The main reason I consented to do this is my disappointment with most writing I have seen, aimed at Russian audiences, on the Russian diaspora church in Belgium.

Why? Simply because a journalist, in a desire to get published, will tell the story his audience wants to hear. You would think that everyone in Russia wants to believe that their Russian diaspora is doing splendidly, with rising church attendance and new buildings.  Added to that, most journalists who come our way lack any independent critical insight.

Sorry, it is too easy to photograph our new churches on a big feast day, with the gaudy colours of a big celebration, and forget the nearly empty Saturday vesper services, or to avoid the question of how many of the new generation we will retain, or indeed the proper role of the Orthodox diaspora in the wider Christian context.

Christ said in the Gospel that ‘the truth will set you free’. Much of what I have read on the ROC in Belgium in the Russian press leaves me in bondage. Will my journalist friend have the key to release the shackles?

If he does not, I will publish the interview independently on this site.


anglomedved: (Default)

October 2015

456789 10


RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 24th, 2017 05:01 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios